长期以来，在涉及西路军问题的有关书刊中，均把１９３６年１０月红四方面军一部西渡黄河说成是执行张国焘的逃跑主义路线，把西路军血战河西走廊遭遇的惨败说成是张国焘路线的最后破产。从中央文献出版社２０００年６月出版的《陈云年谱》中的有关记载看，陈云对西路军长期背 For a long time, in relevant books and periodicals dealing with the issue of the West Route Army, they described the crossing of the Yellow River in the Fourth Red Army across the Yellow River in October 1936 as the escape route for the implementation of Zhang Guotao, and the fiasco suffered by the Hexi corridor in West Route Warfare as It is the final bankruptcy of Zhang Guotao’s route. From the Central Literature Publishing House published in June 2000 << Chen Yun Chronicle >> in the relevant records, Chen Yun West Route Army long-term back