‘文史哲’一九五四年第四期刊载了趙儷生先生的‘南宋金元之際山东、淮海地區中的红襖忠義軍’一文。趙先生在這篇文章里,結合具体史料,給讀者指出了紅襖軍反金鬥爭的基本面貌,並揭露了南宋政府和紅襖軍之間的複雜关係。這些都是非常有益的。不過,趙先生對於李全的評價,我們覺得还有進一步研討的必要。第一,我們認為李全早期的活動,是可以肯定的。这一點必須和當時北 ’Literary history and philosophy’ In the fourth issue of 1954, Mr. Zhao Lisheng’s article entitled ’Red Jacket Loyalist Army in Shandong and Huaihai Region’ was published on the occasion of the Southern Song and Jin Dynasties. In this essay, Mr. Zhao pointed out to readers the basic features of the anti-gold struggle against the Red Army and the complicated relations between the Southern Song government and the Red Army. These are very helpful. However, Mr. Zhao for the evaluation of Lee, we think there is a need for further discussions. First, we think Lee’s early activities are certain. This must be at the time